Blog | Kilburnlad Chasing unicorns (or transcription software!)

Chasing unicorns (or transcription software!)

Occasionally one gets off on the wrong foot and no matter how obvious this becomes you doggedly persevere.

In this case I was investigating transcription software, my aim to be able to obtain text transcripts of French audio or video files to help prepare material for my U3A French groups. By transcription, I mean automatic text generation. After a bit of research I downloaded a trial copy of Ingscribe, which at $99 isn't cheap. I duly loaded an mp3 audio file and waited to see the results. There weren't any !

So for the next couple of hours or so I kept re-reading the instructions, but to no avail. I obtained the 14 day free licence in case the basic free edition was the problem but that made no difference. In desperation I then tried Express Scribe, but with much the same lack of results. I even tried to uninstall Soundflower in case this was creating a conflict, but found that not to be as easy as it sounds (excuse pun) despite running the uninstall script.

Then it dawned on me, perhaps the two applications weren't supposed to produce an automatic transcript but were simply aids to manual transcription. The option of a foot pedal control to stop and start the playback should have alerted me, but tunnel vision prevailed. These apps are obviously aimed at manually capturing the transcript and their power then lies in using that transcript to professionally enhance videos etc.

So a few hours wasted and a bit more knowledge gained, but I'm still no nearer finding an automatic transcribing app, which in this day and age I find astonishing. It appears that pay-by-content services have cornered the market but these can be expensive.

This website doesn't make extensive use of cookies but a small number are required for the correct functioning of the site and to collect anonymous analytical data.